Ninth Edition9ED 150★
Nightmare
rare in Ninth Edition
- Foil
- $6.19
Scryfall, checked 2026-09-07. An informational market estimate, not an appraisal of your copy.
No price history for this printing yet — a chart needs more than one reading, and this one has been priced once so far. It is recorded daily from here.
27 printings of Nightmare
They range from $0.15 to $1,399.99 — a 9333× difference for a card with the same name. The set code and collector number printed along the bottom edge are what tell them apart.
Not sure which one you are holding? OtterDex reads the set code and collector number off the card and tells you.
Limited Edition Beta
LEB 119—
30th Anniversary Edition
30A 412—
Tenth Edition
10E 164★—
Seventh Edition
7ED 150★—
Eighth Edition
8ED 150★—
30th Anniversary Edition
30A 115—
Summer Magic / Edgar
SUM 120—
Limited Edition Alpha
LEA 118$1,399.99
Unlimited Edition
2ED 119$64.79
Intl. Collectors' Edition
CEI 119$22.77
Collectors' Edition
CED 119$17.23
Revised Edition
3ED 120$7.75
Fourth Edition
4ED 150$2.06
Fifth Edition
5ED 184$1.27
Classic Sixth Edition
6ED 146$0.95
Seventh Edition
7ED 150$0.55
Ninth Edition
9ED 150$0.44
Eighth Edition
8ED 150$0.44
Tenth Edition
10E 164$0.37
The List
PLST W17-17$0.32
Magic 2010
M10 107$0.31
Welcome Deck 2017
W17 17$0.29
Magic 2014
M14 108$0.25
Welcome Deck 2016
W16 8$0.17
Magic 2015
M15 276$0.15
Magic Origins
ORI 282$0.15