OtterDex
Nightmare
Set
Intl. Collectors' Edition
Address
CEI 119
Rarity
rare
Finishes
Non-foil
Game
Magic: The Gathering

Nightmare

Intl. Collectors' Editionrare

Non-foil
$22.77

Scryfall, checked 2026-09-07. An informational market estimate, not an appraisal of your copy.

Non-foil over a year

$15.00 → $22.77, up 52% over 126 days

Non-foil over a year$22.77$15.00
2026-05-043 readings2026-09-07

Is this the one you are holding?

The bottom edge of your card should read CEI 119. There are 26 other printings of Nightmare, worth $0.15 to $1,399.99. See all of them.

27 printings of Nightmare

They range from $0.15 to $1,399.99 — a 9333× difference for a card with the same name. The set code and collector number printed along the bottom edge are what tell them apart.

Not sure which one you are holding? OtterDex reads the set code and collector number off the card and tells you.